Friday, May 21, 2010

Nursing in Public

Over the past couple of days, I have heard several stories in the news of women being asked not to nurse in public, and it makes me a little angry.  I think it's ridiculous to ask a woman to go nurse in a bathroom or some other private place, and I guess part of this is because I grew up in Peru.  As a kid, I always saw women nursing their babies in public, and they weren't discreet about it at all.  They would completely pull their breast out in the middle of a church service to feed their baby.  And you know what?  Nobody cared.  Everybody there grew up exposed to this, so nobody thought twice about it.  In Peru, feeding your baby is perceived as a normal, natural behavior - which is exactly what it is.

So why is it such a big deal here in the US?  Why do we see nursing as something dirty that should be done in private?  Why is an exposed breast such a horrifying thing?  (And I should point out that a breast is rarely exposed for more than a second or two during nursing, and not at all if the mother uses a cover.)  I personally did always cover up when I nursed in public - these days Eleanor gets way too distracted so we usually nurse in the car - but it doesn't bother me when people don't.  I really wish that more women would nurse in public because the more it happens, the more our society will come to accept it as part of nature instead of seeing it as "freaky", "creepy", or "disgusting."

I also want to add that anybody who thinks a woman should go nurse in the bathroom has obviously never breastfed.  Just think about the logistics.  For the first 3 or 4 months, it took Eleanor 45-60 minutes to nurse.  Most public restrooms don't have chairs to sit in, nor do they have lids on the toilet that you can pull down and sit on (and those are usually dirty when they do!).  So do you sit on the toilet seat for 45 minutes?  Gross!  Or, do you STAND, holding your 8 to 15 lb baby in your arms for 45 minutes while you nurse?  I don't know about you, but that sounds extremely uncomfortable to me!  On top of all of that, this means that the mother is spending up to an hour in a room by herself while the people she came with are eating their dinner or shopping or whatever it is they are out doing.  It is lonely and isolating.  No wonder more women don't nurse if this is what they are expected to do!

By the way, in Florida women are legally allowed to breastfeed anywhere that they are allowed to be.  It is illegal for a store manager or other person in charge to ask a woman to leave or stop nursing.

4 comments:

Jen said...

I'm going to be completely honest here :)

I was of the camp of I don't care about nursing in public just use a cover or go somewhere discrete...and, that was before I became a mother! I've explained before the difficulties that Cooper and I had with bf and then I pumped for awhile then my supply dried up...ugh, through all of my difficulties (which I've cried about several times as recently as a couple of days ago) what I did gain is an even more of a respect for exclusively breastfeeding mothers. I've been in public with a hungry/screaming infant and I've plopped myself in so many patio sets at stores to give Coop a bottle...no one blinks an eye but I know if a bf mother did the same thing that people would be giving her the grossed out look. I get pissed for bf mothers everywhere. It shouldn't matter how or where you feed your baby in my opinion...It is a shame how sexualized the female breast is in this country...I should say that my opinion has matured since becoming a mother and having friends with babies and being around them while they breastfeed. I will never forget the moments of breastfeeding with Coop and as a country we should do whatever we need to do to encourage this wonderful act being mother and child. I'm 100% pro-breastfeeding mommy that gave it a 100% but due to several factors had to adjust to what my baby needed (and, I know this to be true in my heart and really don't care anymore what people think about my baby receiving formula as he is very loved and well taken care of) and will stand up for any nursing in public mommy!

Jen said...

Yeah, I didn't want to say that about bf moms but I do know a lot that are judgemental...The ones that know what we've been through are wonderful, though but I think formula feeding moms get this rap like we're lazy or didn't try hard enough...I was actually going to write a post about how this judgement feels but decided to wait a few days after your post because I didn't want you to think that I wrote it because of yours...Breast is best but thank God that they're are EXCELLENT formulas out there for those that bf isn't a feasible option anymore...

I just wish that mothers in general would stop being so judgemental...it really starts before the baby even gets here with the debate on drugfree/induced births, elective c-sections, then it goes to co-sleeping, bf/ff, CIO and the list goes on and on...why can't we just say as mothers that as long as your child is safe, healthy, and loved than who cares what parenting style or methods you use???

BTW, I don't know if you know who Dr. Charles Stanley (First Baptist of Atlanta, Intouch ministries) but we go to his church...that's why our church is so big because a lot of people look at him like he's a celebrity...another topic all together!

Hollie said...

I completely agree with you! We're doing the most natural thing possible for our babies, and yet people look at us like freaks.

It's really very sad.

If anyone EVER even thought of asking me to feed my child in a disgustin, germ-ridden bathroom, I would look at them and politely say, "You first! Take your meal, plop yourself down on that toilet seat and eat away."

I try to be descreet as possible or find a nursing room, but if none are available, you can get your sweet bottom, I will sit down right there and feed my hungry baby.

Malou's Mama said...

1st, I am so glad Eleanor is feeling better! Sounds like quite a rough few days.

2nd, I exclusively breastfeed Liam and thank goodness it is very much accepted here in Denmark. I have been wondering how it will be when we are visiting in the US for 2 months this summer...I tend to whip out my boob without a second thought, no matter where I am or who is with or around me. ;)

I also find it disturbing that no matter which way we choose/need to feed our children - breasfeeding or formula feeding - that there are judgments being made...how ridiculous. It is food - either way, it is keeping our children alive and helping them grow up nice and healthy. Amazing to me that it can all be so controversial.

Finally...Liam got some awesome gifts from Peru when my brother was there last month. I thought of you - Peru looks gorgeous! I'd love to hear more about it sometime.